Civic Accountability · Nigeria

NGScorecard

Previously in Kaduna:
Term report
Performance scorecard for key state commissioners — assessed against their stated mandate and verified deliverables. Ratings reflect independent assessment as of April 2026.
10
Commissioners tracked
2
Good
6
Fair
2
Poor
Justice (Attorney-General)
Sule Shuaibu
Fair
Mandate
Serve as the state's chief law officer, including representing the state in the 2023 governorship election petition defence.
Performance assessment
Held the justice portfolio through the successful defence of Governor Sani's election at tribunal, Court of Appeal, and Supreme Court level; independently verified broader performance data was not identified for this entry.
Finance
Shizzer Nasara Joy Bada
Fair
Mandate
Manage state fiscal policy during the administration's first phase, including the initial debt-repayment strategy.
Performance assessment
Served in the initial 2023 cabinet before the finance portfolio was later held by Ibrahim Tanko Mohammed; independently verified individual performance assessment was not identified for this entry.
Education
Prof. Muhammad Sani Bello
Good
Mandate
Oversee basic and post-basic education policy, including the drive to reduce out-of-school children.
Performance assessment
Served through a period in which out-of-school children fell from roughly 550,000 to 187,720, alongside 736 new classrooms built and 10,000 teachers recruited.
Health
Umma Kaltume Ahmed
Fair
Mandate
Oversee the state's healthcare system and public health policy.
Performance assessment
Served through a period of recruitment of roughly 1,800 primary healthcare workers subsequently migrated to the CONMESS/CONHESS salary structures; independently verified individual performance assessment was not identified for this entry.
Local Government
Sadiq Mamman Lagos
Poor
Mandate
Oversee local government administration and the disbursement of federation account allocations to the state's 23 councils.
Performance assessment
Served through a period in which the state was reported to have withheld federal allocations from its 23 local government councils for several months, in alleged violation of the Supreme Court's 2024 local government financial autonomy directive.
Public Works and Infrastructure
Ibrahim Hamza
Good
Mandate
Deliver the administration's road and infrastructure programme.
Performance assessment
Served during the initiation of about 150 road projects covering over 1,300km across the state's 23 local government areas.
Planning and Budget Commission
Mukhtar Ahmed
Fair
Mandate
Oversee state planning and budget preparation amid rapidly rising budgets and a no-new-loans fiscal policy.
Performance assessment
Served through a period of rapid budget growth (₦458.27bn in 2024 to ₦985.9bn by 2026); independently verified individual performance assessment was not identified for this entry.
Internal Security and Home Affairs
Auwal Musa Shugaba
Poor
Mandate
Coordinate the state's security response to banditry and communal violence during the administration's first phase.
Performance assessment
Served during a period in which Southern Kaduna violence continued and a November 2024 peace accord subsequently broke down; the portfolio was later reassigned to Dr. James Atung Kanyip.
Housing and Urban Development
Abdullahi Aminu Shagali
Fair
Mandate
Oversee housing policy and urban development, drawing on his prior experience as a former Speaker of the Kaduna State House of Assembly.
Performance assessment
Served through the standard term; independently verified sector-specific outcome data was not identified for this entry.
Humanitarian Affairs
Barde Yunana Markus
Fair
Mandate
Lead the newly created Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs, coordinating support for communities displaced by banditry and communal violence.
Performance assessment
Served as the ministry's inaugural commissioner during a period of continued displacement from Southern Kaduna violence; independently verified outcome data was not identified for this entry.