Civic Accountability · Nigeria

NGScorecard

Previously in Kaduna:
Term report
4
Inherited problems
2
Fixed
1
Partial progress
Fixed
Partial progress
Security
Decades-long southern Kaduna communal and farmer-herder conflict
Broken
The problem
El-Rufai took office inheriting a long-running cycle of communal, ethnic, and farmer-herder violence in southern Kaduna that predated his administration by years.
What was done
The violence continued through both of his terms; he characterised it publicly as a cycle of attacks and reprisals rather than a problem his administration resolved.
Infrastructure
Abandoned Zaria water infrastructure
Partial
The problem
The Zaria water works had sat abandoned for roughly 30 years before contractors returned to the site under El-Rufai.
What was done
A ₦24bn AfDB/IsDB-funded expansion project was commissioned in 2019, but was reported to be near collapse again by the end of his tenure.
Governance
Bloated, inefficient state civil service
Fixed
The problem
El-Rufai's administration described the civil service it inherited as oversized and inefficient relative to the state's revenue base.
What was done
A public service reform and revitalisation programme launched in 2016 led to large-scale downsizing through 2017-2021, which the administration presented as fixing the structural cost problem, though the manner of the layoffs was widely contested.
Economy
Low internally generated revenue base
Fixed
The problem
Kaduna's IGR stood at roughly ₦11.5 billion in 2015, leaving the state heavily dependent on federal allocations.
What was done
IGR grew more than fivefold over his two terms to roughly ₦58 billion by 2023.